Newsletter comparison
Big Salad vs Earl Earl by Laurel Pantin
Short answer: Choose Big Salad for an intimate mix of style and personal life. Choose Earl Earl for close observation of how other people actually dress. Keep both if the person and occasion matter as much as the item.[1][2][3][4][5][6]
An independent guide. Scottie isn't affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Big Salad and Earl Earl by Laurel Pantin. Each publication owns its name, writing, and subscription terms.
A brief from both newsletters · July 31, 2026
See both newsletters in one brief
See what made the brief, what didn't, and the original links behind every included story.
In this brief: Scottie kept the selected stories separate because they added different value.
Reader priorities
A reader wants personality-led style that remains connected to relationships, family, and the ordinary scenes clothes are worn through.
These are illustrative priorities, not a customer’s data.
What made the brief
- Big Salad2 read · 1 included
- Earl Earl by Laurel Pantin3 read · 3 included
Scottie
Scottie example brief
July 31, 2026 · Executive brief
01 / The rundown
- Laurel Pantin shared how getting matching tattoos with her father inspired deeper engagement with her young children's daily creative interests and media choices.
- Laurel Pantin highlighted versatile vacation wardrobe staples at Earl IRL while opening pre-orders for her upcoming personal style guide and fall shoes.
02 / The briefing
01 / main
Laurel Pantin reflects on getting matching tattoos with her dad
The takeaway: Laurel Pantin got matching ink with her father two years ago after he asked her to take him for his first tattoo. Bonding over shared experiences inspired her to embrace her own young kids' favorite books, podcasts, and movies.
Concrete details
- Pantin got her first tattoo at age 17 and now wears inked drawings created by her children.
- Her children are ages 6 and 8, driving her search for family-friendly media recommendations.
Why it matters for this reader: This heartfelt story highlights how shared aesthetic choices with aging parents and young kids deepen everyday family connections through personal style.
Original sourcesEarl Earl by Laurel Pantin
02 / main
Earl IRL showcases versatile summer vacation packing pieces for August
The takeaway: Laurel Pantin selected top summer travel pieces at her store, Earl IRL, ahead of August travels. Highlights include flowy skirts with pockets, multi-use sets, terry tees, and pre-orders for fall Herbert Levine footwear.
Concrete details
- High Sport floral pants in size XS remain available before Pantin claims them at week's end.
- Flore Flore tops allow building a full vacation wardrobe with just one button-down, tee, and tank.
Why it matters for this reader: Smart packing choices combine ease with real family routines, making effortless, practical wardrobe pieces fit everyday summer trips.
Original sourcesEarl Earl by Laurel Pantin
03 / main
Laurel Pantin previews her upcoming book and fall shoe pre-orders
The takeaway: Laurel Pantin promoted her new personal style book, What to Wear Every Day, alongside an extended shop update. She shared end-of-summer wardrobe recommendations, including suede clogs, woven shorts, and pre-orders for fall shoes.
Concrete details
- Marrakishi Life rainbow woven mensy shorts retail for $400 for peak end-of-summer styling.
- Abi Ame Summer Skin fragrance-free body moisturizer dries instantly and sells for $29.
Why it matters for this reader: Perfect for refreshing your wardrobe with thoughtful, lived-in style that transitions smoothly from late summer family pools to crisp fall afternoons.
Original sourcesEarl Earl by Laurel Pantin
04 / main
New ask-me-anything edition answers candid questions on relationships and life
The takeaway: The latest subscriber Q&A issue tackles deeply personal reader questions spanning relationships, sex after divorce, and celebrity encounters. To celebrate the sixth ask-me-anything edition, new annual subscriptions are currently discounted by 20 percent.
Concrete details
- Annual subscriptions feature a 20 percent discount this week for new members.
- Subscribers gain full access to the publication's entire deep archive of past issues.
Why it matters for this reader: Offers an intimate look into personal relationships and life choices, echoing your interest in candid, family-centered stories.
Original sourcesBig Salad
Action items
- Pre-order Laurel Pantin's book, What to Wear Every Day, to discover practical style tips for busy daily routines.
- Email Earl IRL to reserve fall Herbert Levine footwear or claim multi-use vacation pieces before August travel begins.
See every issue behind this brief
Matching Tattoos with Dad
- Kids Entertainment I Also Kind of LoveEarl Earl by Laurel Pantin · Included
Vacation Outfits and Packing Ideas
- Vacation Outfits via Earl IRLEarl Earl by Laurel Pantin · Included
Personal Style Book and Store Updates
- Saturday Snack: Surfy Things for End of SummerEarl Earl by Laurel Pantin · Included
Big Salad July Edit
- The July EditBig Salad · Read, not included
Relationships and Personal AMA
- Freddie Texted Me the Funniest ThingBig Salad · Included
The useful difference
The difference that matters
Big Salad combines warm personal updates with a monthly style edit. Earl Earl studies outfits through observed people, travel, and the social life surrounding the clothes.[1][2][3][4][5][6]
What each is best for
Big Salad
Big Salad contributes personal stories, recurring edits, and a warm account of how style travels through relationships and everyday life.[1][2][3]
Earl Earl by Laurel Pantin
Earl Earl contributes observed outfits, vacation dressing, family scenes, and detailed attention to the character of the wearer.[4][5][6]
When it’s worth reading both
The pair treats style as lived rather than displayed. Scottie can group related outfit ideas while retaining the person, setting, and tone that give each one meaning.[1][2][3][4][5][6]